← UC-341: Three Stars, Three Exits
Companion · UC-341

Who Waits Longer

Three Olympic champions under contract asked their NHL teams to trade them in 2026. Ottawa moved fast. Winnipeg and Detroit suspended without pay and waited. Then, on October 30, a fourth star asked out, and Tampa Bay refused. Here is how the exits compare.

1 · Three exits, one summer

From the trade request to the trade, June to the end of October 2026.

JunJulAugSepOctnow
Asked out, still with the team Suspended without pay Traded Team refuses to trade

Positions within a month are approximate where reports give only the month. Tkachuk was traded in June; Hellebuyck’s suspension ran from training camp to October 23, the day of his trade; Larkin was held out and suspended on October 29.

Update, October 31: a fourth star asked out. Nikita Kucherov, the reigning MVP, told Tampa Bay he will not re-sign and requested a trade in the last year of his contract, with a ten-team list. Tampa answered a third way: “We unequivocally have no intention of trading Nikita.” He did not play at the 2026 Olympics, so a shared gold cannot explain all four requests.

2 · The lists

A no-trade or no-movement clause lets a player name the only teams he will accept. Press the button to see where two lists meet.

Brady Tkachuk · 4 teams
Dylan Larkin · first 3 teams

Larkin’s list has since reportedly grown to about ten teams. Florida won the Stanley Cup in 2024 and 2025; Florida and Nevada have no state income tax.

3 · The cost of every day

A suspended player is not paid. Move the slider to see roughly what holding out costs a player earning about $8.7 million a year, the average value of Larkin’s contract.

Days held out24
Salary given up$0

Illustration only: assumes pay is spread evenly over about 186 days of the regular season and uses the contract’s average annual value; a player’s actual salary in a given season can differ. For comparison, reporters estimated Hellebuyck’s forfeit at about $925,000.

4 · What history says

Earlier stars who asked out under contract, and how their teams answered.

Team waited

Alexei Yashin

Ottawa, 1999–2000. Suspended for the season; an arbitrator ruled he still owed the contract year. Traded in 2001 for Zdeno Chára, Bill Muckalt and the No. 2 pick, Jason Spezza.

Moved fast

Chris Pronger

Edmonton, 2006. Asked out weeks after a Cup final, one year into a five-year deal; traded to Anaheim ten days later. Won the Cup there in 2007.

Moved fast

Matthew Tkachuk

Calgary, 2022. Said he would not sign long term; traded to Florida two days later for a package led by Jonathan Huberdeau. Cups in 2024 and 2025.

The pattern, not a law: when the team waits, it tends to get more back; when the team moves fast, the player tends to get what he wanted.

A companion visual to UC-341 · Three Stars, Three Exits, a StratIQX case study. It illustrates the subject; it is not part of the case’s scored analysis. None of the three players has stated a reason for asking out.
Sources: NHL.com, ESPN, Yahoo Sports, Daily Faceoff, CTV News, PuckPedia; history from reference pages. Salary figures are estimates.